A programmed end with uncertain effects in Belgium
The temporary protection granted to displaced persons from Ukraine in Europe, activated since March 2022, is set to expire on March 4, 2028, with no prospect of further extension. In Belgium, about 70,600 beneficiaries are affected. This deadline raises a central question: what residence solutions are available after the end of the system, while the conditions for a safe return to Ukraine are still not met according to European authorities and the Council of Europe.
The current regime is based on an exceptional European framework. Its programmed disappearance creates a risk of a massive shift to the classic foreigner law regimes, without an automatic transition mechanism. Belgium will therefore have to individually address thousands of situations within a short timeframe, with an already strained administrative capacity.
The asylum route: legally open but impractical in practice
Legally, beneficiaries can submit an asylum application at any time. However, Belgium is not currently examining these applications systematically during the temporary protection.
A generalization of this option would lead to:
- massive congestion at the General Commissioner for Refugees and Stateless Persons;
- processing times that could extend over several years;
- a global administrative blockage, confirmed by recent European case law prohibiting return measures as long as the application is not examined.
Concrete avenues to consider in Belgium
Economic pathways : a solution limited in practice
The alternatives proposed by the European Union rely on existing residence permits (work, study, family reunification, single permit, EU Blue Card). In Belgium, their implementation faces several constraints :
- processing times already excessive for the single permit ;
- high economic requirements for self-employed workers and processing times exceeding reasonable limits ;
- qualification and salary criteria excluding a significant portion of beneficiaries, including those integrated for several years in sectors with shortages (transport, construction, horeca...).
The B card : a possible change of status, but without guarantee
A change of status to the B card is technically feasible. However :
- no automatic right to the B card exists, even after five years of residence under temporary protection ;
- it remains uncertain whether the years spent under this status will be taken into account in the calculation of residence seniority in case of transition to another title (e.g. : employee single permit) ;
- in these hybrid situations, the decision belongs to the discretionary assessment of the Immigration Office (DVZ), without automatic legal guarantee.
The B card nevertheless presents an indirect advantage : once obtained, it paves the way for a request for a L card.
The L card : the status of long-term resident
The L permit (long-term resident — third-country national) offers a stronger perspective of stability. Key points:
- the years spent under temporary protection can be taken into account to meet the requirement of five years of legal and uninterrupted residence;
- however, it is not possible to directly apply for an L permit from temporary protection status, as it falls under an excluded category;
- a prior change of status is essential, to a non-excluded title: employed worker (excluding au pair, seasonal, or posted), self-employed worker, or family reunification;
- it is only after this change of legal basis that an application for an L permit can be submitted.
A call for legislative creativity
A solution must be found by March 4, 2027. The only conceivable and coherent voice is a rapid adaptation of the regulations to set strict, yet clear criteria for transitioning from temporary protection status to another status.
This adaptation will allow for
- protecting the employer sectors that are currently dependent on this workforce.
- preserve the administrative security of the interested parties;
- avoid the congestion of already overwhelmed administrative bodies (asylum / professional cards / single permit);
- maintain the social and economic cohesion built since 2022.
The deadline is known. Time is running out. The pragmatism that guided the response in 2022 must, once again, inspire the Belgian legislator.
Anna Sussarova & Anna Kolesnikova
Lawyers
T.: +32493419868
info@pravolex.be
Our latest content
Discover the new features in our company!